share
POST

Should Hillary Have Reporters Over For Beer?

What the U.S. media needs to learn about its own sexism

Just a week ago, my friend Doris and I were wondering if the Henry Gates affair would have caused such a stir if it involved an angry woman instead of an angry man.  Naahh, we decided, although we didn't really have any hard evidence. "If a woman had gotten angry like Gates did, she wouldn't have gotten sympathy, she would have been called a bitch," Doris declared. 

Then, as if on cue, Hillary Clinton lost her cool in Africa.  A few days later, she was the butt of "Biach" jokes.

Last Thursday, for example, on MSNBC’s Morning Joe, Joe Scarborough's office-wife Mika Brzezinski announced, "Coming up, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton making more news on her trip in Africa.” Joe quipped, "It was positive, right? She didn't, like, blow up, did she?"  Mika flashed him her usual disapproving-wife grin, and admonished, "I think this is something important.”

Not to whine or anything, but why did the issue of race become a teachable moment for the White House after the Henry Gates affair, but no teachable moments have been extracted when the Secretary of State exhibits anger over being seen as joined at her husband's hip? When Gates lost his temper, the issue of race became the fodder for countless sympathetic news stories, but a similar flare-up of tempers and misunderstood innuendos around Hillary in Africa has spawned the uncomfortable jokes that are customary when a powerful woman gets angry. 

At the risk of getting into a  "who is more oppressed" fest, here's what I think: This kind of thing happens because while racism and sexism are both institutionalized in our country—woven deep into the fabric of everyday life so that we barely notice them much of the time—sexism is still more deeply institutionalized.  When George McGovern announced in 2007 it would be harder to elect a woman to the White House than a black man, his sentiments were echoed by black women in politics, who said they ran into more sexism than racism on the job.

While posts about the Gates affair were—and still are--burning up Facebook and Twitter, I've seen about an eighth of the comments about Hillary, and they are mostly jokes.  Even editor Tina Brown accidentally slipped into institutionalized sexism when she was trying to excuse HRC for being testy because she was tired: "Look, she's in her second week in Africa. She's hot, she feels fat..." Brown might as well have said she was menopausal, or PMS-ing. 

For the record, as of Friday, Mika was still scolding and reining in Joe to "be nice to Hillary."

15 readers liked this story.
Mor_ad_602x100_fab_2
Comments
11.11.2009
Nancy Wurtzel
Wow, this story is so right-on. Kathryn captured the sexism surrounding this non-issue. We expect perfection from our female leaders, but Hillary is human just like Joe and the rest of the media boys. And, I do mean boys. She'll show them all in the end as she is doing such a great job in difficult times. However, there will always be those males (and a few females) who will love to drag her down over her hair style, pants suits, laugh lines, etc. Hang in there Hillary!
08.22.2009
DIANE WAGNER
Does Hillary even like beer? ;o) In my personal opinion, no, she shouldn't have reporters over for beer. Business is business, pleasure is pleasure.
08.19.2009
MegF
And interesting how Sotomayor was a racist but not a sexist ... great article, keep 'em coming!
08.19.2009
Louise Nayer
Wonderful to point out the gender inequities in how we treat people--here and abroad. Great article!
08.19.2009
Phred Pohl
True enough. Although one big difference is that Clinton is Secretary of State, while Gates is a relatively private citizen. And the offense against him came from a cop on official business -- and he got arrested -- while she got a stupid question from a female student. The behavior bar is much higher in her case. She could have just given a dirty look and said "next question," which would have made her thoughts clear without providing fodder for cable news jerks.
Mor_ad_300x150_fab_b
most liked
Loader_buff
Other topics you might appreciate