MAC promises a lot: thicker lashes, no clumping, the blackest color—and no irritation. Did this mascara ($15; Click to Buy) turn our testers into believers? Yes, it did. “I’ve been using the same mascara since high school, so I was skeptical of this product. What could be better than my standby? But I loved the brush, and the product went on easily and without clumping. My lashes looked so long, a couple of people asked me if I was wearing false ones! I’m converted,” gushed one tester.
Which skincare products scored highest with readers? Click here to find out.
Want MORE great beauty articles like this? Click here to sign up for our weekly newsletter!