The Hormone Hoax Thousands Fall For

Lab tests conducted for More show that hormones custom-made to boost your well-being may do more harm than good

by Cathryn Jakobson Ramin
hormone hoax illustration
Photograph: Mark Allen Miller

Additional reporting by Jillian Keenan and Elizabeth Savage. The Fund for Investigative Journalism provided some financial support for this article.

Next: A Texas Rebel Fights for Her Land

Want MORE? Sign up for our weekly newsletter here!

First published in the October 2013 issue

Share Your Thoughts!


Karen 02.28.2015

It's perfectly reasonable to be skeptical of "alternatives," but I would've preferred to see just as much skepticism of the "traditional" approaches, which have, in large part, gotten plenty wrong. It's not like the FDA, the pharmaceutical industry, and their audience-doctors are exactly without flaws. It's not like it is only the alternative doctors who are in it "for the money" as this article implies. In fact, many of the theories and approaches of the bioidentical hormone movement that were heavily criticized years ago, are now being adopted by the pharmaceutical industry, who have more of the money to prove their worth through convenient testing. Now, thanks in large part to the alternative movement, hormone replacement therapy, once deemed "dangerous" is now considered "beneficial," even for BRCA patients. I also would've preferred that More quoted not just Somers' books, but more of the BHT doctors. I would've loved to hear their defense. This article was chock-full of quotes and interviews from, basically, just the opponents.

Arros 12.18.2013

Working for Wyeth are we?
You write as if you took only the worse-case scenarios, stretch the "fear factor" and sensationalize anything about compounding and put an article together to sell advertisements. Good for you for putting your bottom dollar first and not explore more into what BHRT has done for hundreds of thousands of women who get tens of thousands of different customized medications.
Also, the Estriol fiasco was debunked a long time ago when Wyeth themselves marketed Estriol in Europe as a "wonder drug". I guess I'll be looking at MORE LESS!!!!


As a woman who has tried both bioidentical and FDA approved HRT I am shocked by the misleading and quite frankly, slanderous spin of this article. I could write a novel about the years I tried to help my body get through menopause with chemical "equivalents". I could write another novel about how a Naturopathic physician who prescribed compounded BHRT (in cream form, which is better absorbed than pill form) helped me feel like a vibrant woman again, not some nut job bouncing off walls, growing facial hair and a penis from the one-size-fits-all FDA approved horse urine therapy. But I will simply say this, your story is blatantly irresponsible and will only serve to get more women interested in drugs, which will help the FDA to achieve its goal of tapping into that $2.5 billion dollar biodentical "industry". The government needs to get its hands off of my body and moreover, my constitutional right to choose what I put into it. Thank you very much, I'll pick yams over pregnant horse urine every time.

Post new comment

Click to add a comment