20 Naughty (and Nice) Finds

Whether you’re dressing up as a good witch or a bad witch, we found the perfect makeup for you!

Images loading...

Bad Witch: Chanel Vamp Nail Colour

 Rumored to be modeled after the color of dried blood, this blackened red has become a cult classic.


($25; Click to purchase)


Good Witch: OPI Nail Lacquer in Teenage Dream

A pink glitter polish Glenda the Good Witch would love.


$9; Click to purchase


Bad Witch: Lipstick Queen Sinner 90 Percent Pigment Lipstick in Rouge Sinner

Delightfully devious, this red lipstick contains rubber pigment (yes you read that right) said to keep the matte formula from drying out your lips.


$18; Click to purchase

Space NK

Good Witch: Nars Lip Gloss in Sweet Dreams

This pretty-in-pale-pink gloss uses just a hint of shimmer to leave your lips with a demure finish.


$24; Click to purchase


Bad Witch: Fresh Cannabis Santal Eau De Parfum

Yum. This scent is a naughty mix of patchouli, cannabis, rose—and a hint of chocolate.


$75; Click to purchase


Good Witch: Prada Candy Eau de Parfum

A cocktail of musk, caramel and benzoin-this scent is so sweet you'll get a sugar high.


$108; Click to purchase

Neiman Marcus

Bad Witch: Bumble and Bumble Bb Texture Undressing Creme

The anti-polish product, this gel-creme creates gritty, textured morning-after hair.


$26; Click to purchase


Good Witch: Fekkai Glossing Cream with Pure Olive Oil

Score perfectly-polished good girl locks with this moisturizing gloss cream.


$23; Click to purchase


Bad Witch: Urban Decay Afterglow Glide-On Cheek Tint in Greedy

A rich plum blush that mimics the flush of afterglow...


$24; Click to purchase

Urban Decay

Good Witch: Tarte Cheek Stain in Natural Beauty

This cheek stain makes you look like you're a health nut just back from a run.


$30; Click to purchase


Bad Witch: Tokyo Milk Skull with Roses Bubble Bath

Can a bubble bath be menacing? We love this luxe formula, scented with exotic wood, ebony, and deep vanilla.


$22; Click to purchase


Good Witch: Philosophy Falling in Love Perfumed Romantic Bath & Shower Gel

A sparkling berry-scented bath & shower gel that will appeal to hopeless romantics.



$22; Click to purchase


Bad Witch: Joya Gunpowder Green Tea Fragrance Diffuser

Double, double toil and trouble...This unique home fragrance diffuser may look forbidding but its notes of shiso tea leaf, white mint and cape jasmine create a surprisingly homey scent.


$76; Click to purchase

Barneys New York

Good Witch: Good Home Co. Sheet and Clothing Spray in Beach Days

Can you think of a nicer scent than eau de beach house? Us either.


$20; Click to purchase


Bad Witch: Guerlain Terracotta Khol Kajal Eyeliner

A creamy khol liner in a goof-proof applicator makes a dramatic, smokey eye a cinch.


$36; Click to purchase


Good Witch: Smashbox Eye Beam Double-Ended Brightener

Get that bright-eyed and bushy-tailed look with this highlighting and brightening pencil. 


$22; Click to purchase


Too Faced Size Queen Black Mascara

The enormous brush in this volumizing mascara creates intimidatingly thick (and impossible-to-miss) lashes.


$21; Click to purchase

Too Face Size Queen Mascara

Good Witch: Tarte Lash Hugger Eco-Friendly Mascara

Free of fragrance and parabens and packaged in recycled aluminum, this do-gooder mascara creates she-coulda-been-born-with-them long lashes.


$18; Click to purchase


Bad Witch: Diptyque Baies Noire Candle

A sultry Diptyque scent (a blend of rose and blackcurrant) packaged in luxe black glass is séance-worthy. 


$90; Click to purchase


Good Witch: MOR Essentials Honey Nectar Scented Candle

This de-lish blend of sweet brown sugar, candied almonds, honey and warm vanilla milk is like a comforting cup of hot tea.


$18; Click to purchase


Want the latest beauty, fashion and lifestyle tips? Click here to sign up for our fabulous weekly newsletter!


Click here for Celeb Makeup Artist's Fall Must-Haves


First Published October 4, 2011

Share Your Thoughts!


Post new comment

Click to add a comment
Member Voices
Shoes & Accessories
Woman of Style and Substance
Swim & Lingerie