“For a better fruit chew, choose Welch’s Fruit Snacks,” says Zuckerbrot. “Most of the sugar in this treat comes from actual fruit. Plus, it contains 100 percent of the recommended daily intake for vitamin C.”

Click here to buy

All it takes to curb chocolate cravings is a few bites, says Zuckerbrot. So when you’re in need of a chocolate fix, opt for Hershey's Kisses. Two Kisses have only 50 calories and 2.5 grams fat. Make your morsels dark chocolate for an antioxidant boost.

Click here to buy

“In this case, a Dum Dum lollipop is actually the smart decision,” says Zuckerbrot. One of these fat-free lollipops has just 20 calories and five grams of carbohydrates.

Click here to buy

Instead of candies you can swallow in one gulp, get your jollies with Jolly Ranchers this Halloween. “Go wild and have three,” Zuckerbrot jokes. “They’ll only set you back 50 calories and seven grams of sugar.”

Click here to buy

Skinny Cow Heavenly Crisp Peanut Butter and Chocolate candy bars manage to combine the classic flavors of peanut butter and chocolate with fewer than half the calories of a Butterfinger. You’re in for a treat when you can trick your taste buds into believing you’re munching on something decadent.

Click here to buy

If you’re hankering for some M&M’s, reach for a Fun Size-version of the peanut kind. Peanuts are a great source of protein, says nutritionist Elizabeth Somer, author of Eat Your Way to Happiness. Her belief: If covering it in chocolate means you’ll eat more of a good thing, then go for it.

Click here to buy

For the same tangy and tart taste you’d get in Pixy Stix, suck on their solid form: SweeTarts. Because these take longer to eat, your sweet tooth will be satisfied longer. Eight pieces contain 50 calories and 13 grams of carbs.

Click here to buy

Jelly Belly managed to do what it does best (again) by capturing candy-corn flavor in a four-calorie jelly bean. And each piece has only one gram of carbohydrates.

Click here to buy

For a surprisingly sweet treat, add KIND mini bars to your bowl of Halloween candy. The bars contain all-natural ingredients and come in a variety of flavors to satisfy every craving from a decadent drizzle of chocolate to sweet fruit or salty nuts.

Click here to buy

For a sweet treat after dinner, chew on fruit-flavored sugar-free gum like Trident Tropical Twist, suggests Mark Macdonald, RD, Chelsea Handler’s personal nutritionist and the author of Body Confidence. The long-lasting citrus flavor will help satiate your craving for sweets without promoting cavities or providing hidden calories. One piece of Trident contains fewer than three and a half calories.

Click here to buy

Related: Best New Belly-Slimming Snacks

Don’t miss out on MORE great articles like this one. Click here to sign up for our weekly newsletter!