Is It Time to Break Up With Facebook?

A digital media strategist discusses the latest dilemma in her love-hate relationship with social media: Facebook Timeline

by Jennifer Mirsky
jennifer mirsky image
Jennifer Mirsky
Photograph: Ellen Dubin Photography.

A colleague once dubbed me “Little Miss Cyber-Privacy.” The moniker didn’t sting, even though I work in digital media and have been ribbed before for my reluctance to share (or overshare, depending on your perspective). Truth is, I’ve guarded my privacy long before my journeys in cyberspace — since I was a child — and I see no reason to stop now. Especially now. But social media keeps growing in popularity, and it gets harder and harder to avoid divulging the kind of information we privacy freaks would rather keep to ourselves.

With Facebook Timeline, the social network’s revamped profile design, those concerned about privacy should ponder what they’re willing to reveal and whether connection trumps privacy in this brave new world. That’s because Timeline is not just a catalogue of your online experiences, or even of your education and work history (as on LinkedIn). It is really, truly, and I would add madly, a timeline of your life starting with where and on what date you were born.

Facebook Timeline is the latest dilemma of my love-hate relationship with technological progress and communication tools. I’m smack in the middle of the twenty-somethings, who share everything and text all day, and the sixty-year-olds, who think we’ve all lost our heads, preferring the old-fashioned telephone or — oh horror! — face-to-face. Still favoring email over texts, I adopt the latest advances because my career mandates it, and because I’m genuinely interested, but I try to do so on my own terms.

For instance, in an effort to establish a work-life balance, I long resisted giving out my personal cell phone number at work, figuring I was already reachable round the clock via email, with my ever-present BlackBerry. This solution worked well for years, until none other than the White House requested my cell number for a 2007 piece we were doing at on First Lady Laura Bush. I reluctantly obliged. (Consoling me, a colleague said, “Don’t worry — they probably already had it.”)

At other times, I harnessed the anonymity of the web, taking solace in its freedom of expression and lack of geographic constraint. When the decision to start a family evolved into a harrowing ordeal, virtual strangers offered support and insight that trumped what would have been forthcoming, in my judgment, from lifelong “real world” relationships. In more joyous times, I had fun impersonating my dog on his blog and social media channels (“Why Bark When You Can Blog? Confessions of a Portuguese Water Dog”). He ignored the strong scent of Foursquare, finding no reason to broadcast his whereabouts or declare himself “mayor” of his favorite spot. He is my alter ego after all.

But now there’s Facebook Timeline, and the network requires “everyone to provide their real names, so you always know who you're connecting with.” In other words, anonymous handles and pseudonyms be gone! My reservations about fleshing out my Timeline have run the gamut from neurotic (or cautious, again depending on your perspective) concerns about identity theft, to what is probably widespread ambivalence about combining one’s personal and work lives, to the vagaries of my own particular comfort zone.

Facebook prompted me to add a cover photo (which I did willingly, being of the visual school) and life events (which I declined). Even though I chose to leave off such personally identifiable information as my birthday and school graduation dates and to hide some other information I’d already supplied, I soon realized that the new profile display was as telling for what was omitted as for what was included. But I asked myself if I really wanted to spell out the personal details of my life on my Facebook Timeline — the milestones that happened and when, the milestones that didn’t happen, the milestones that were in the process of happening. I concluded, no, I did not.

Who doesn’t have periods in their lives that they’d rather gloss over? Fortunately, I’ve had steady work during tough economic times, but many can’t say that. And I well understood the apprehension of my friend Monica (pseudonym) who imagined her Facebook Timeline looking like this: January 2008: “Married.” February 2009: “Single.” March 2009: “It’s complicated.” April 2009: “Single.” You get the idea.

A filled-in Timeline captures a fairly complete picture of you, in snapshot view, optionally including what you’re listening to, reading, or watching, thanks to the new social apps. True to form, I decided not to embrace them all. Pinterest, the hot online pinboard, ensnared me in its visually addictive clutches as did Spotify, where “music is social,” but I opted to keep the news readers at bay, preferring not to share what I was reading in real time with my 500 Facebook friends. (As a case in point, I learned from Facebook that a colleague had read a Washington Post article about what liquid substance was traveling down Christina Aguilera’s leg. My day was none the richer for that discovery.)

“Enough whining,” you might reasonably say. “No one’s forcing you to be on Facebook.” I would concur. Facebook reminds me of a lover who’s not good for you but whom you can’t quite renounce. What’s a girl to do? I could leave Facebook — but who’s kidding who? — or take a break and see how much we miss each other. I could delete my old posts — but who has the time? For now, I’ve adjusted my privacy settings, friend list, and “liked” pages, and occasionally enabled Spotify’s private sessions. (No need to telegraph a blue mood to 500 people based on my music selections. No need to beg the question of why.)

I’m still engaged in a battle of wills between my unwavering desire for privacy and Facebook’s decree that we share every aspect of our lives on their platform. But let’s get past me, since I am a bit of a contradiction (more wired than many, more private than most). Has Facebook finally alienated your affection, or do you find Facebook as irresistible as ever?

Jennifer Mirsky is a digital media strategist who has led editorial teams in the creation and production of award-winning sites, including those of Hearst and Time Inc., as well as Meredith, where she served as Editor-in-Chief of Women’s Lifestyle, Meredith Interactive. Her consulting clients have encompassed start-ups, hyperlocal, and global luxury brands.

First Published Mon, 2012-04-16 11:58

Find this story at: