Menu Join now Search

She Thinks I Never Do Anything Right. So Why Even Try?

She says she's sick of doing all the housework. He says her nagging is bringing him down. Can this marriage be saved?


The Couple

Kate: 36, nonprofit manager
Brendan: 38, software developer
Married: 9 years
Kids: Aidan, 6, and Max, 4

The Counselor

Stephanie Whitman, Chicago

The Background

Kate wants Brendan to help out; he thinks she's a nag and feels criticized when he does pitch in. To escape he's been staying out late with his buddies. Kate worries he's got a drinking problem and that their marriage is doomed.

Kate: This is so not the life I envisioned. When we were dating I was upfront with Brendan about the future I wanted — a career, a family, and a husband who'd share the childrearing and chores. Brendan agreed to an equal partnership. Famous last words! If he'd do his fair share, I wouldn't have to bark orders like a drill sergeant. Brendan works from home, so you'd think he'd find time for a few chores. What's wrong with him?

Brendan: Nothing's wrong with me. Our standards and priorities are way different and Kate chews me out if I don't do things exactly the way she wants. Kate expects all the toys to be put away every night, but what's the point if they'll come out again the next day? It's a big deal to her if Aidan and Max's socks don't match, but as long as the kids are safe and healthy I don't care whether they wear one blue sock and one brown one. Why should I waste time in the morning finding them matching socks?

Kate's a perfectionist. She'll walk into a room, find the one thing that's wrong out of 100 things that are right, and go ballistic. I won't notice that a light has been left on — until Kate says, "I wonder who didn't turn off the light again?" I've stopped trying to please her. When we're together she berates me for what I'm not doing — or doing wrong — and then gives me the silent treatment. I hate fighting, so at night I hide out in my office or hang out in bars with my friends. It's the only relief I get.

Kate: Brendan says "perfectionist" like it's a four-letter word. Yes, I'm a perfectionist. And a proud one. I won't apologize for having high standards or wanting Brendan to be a good role model for our sons. If he leaves clothes around, Aidan and Max will think it's okay to do the same. I'm mad that Brendan's so disengaged from our family life. He's been working on his company so much that he's oblivious to what it takes to keep things running smoothly at home. If he paid attention, he'd understand that I need more support, especially in the morning. I've got an hour to get ready for work, take the boys to school, and get to the office on time, so I need Brendan to get them dressed and fed as well as make their lunches and pack their backpacks. But more often than not he'll take a call from a client in Tokyo without telling me first. I hate scrambling around and that's when I start yelling — not the best way to begin the day.

Brendan: Here's the deal: I'm an entrepreneur, so my work never ends and my schedule is consistently inconsistent. I have to take calls from Asia first thing in the morning because of the time difference. Kate should know this by now. Instead of getting pissed at me, she should stop staying up until 2&nbap;a.m. posting photos on Facebook. Then she could wake up before 6:45 and she wouldn't have to rush. It's not my fault that she cuts it too close.

Kate: Well, evenings aren't much better. Brendan is still in his office when I bring the boys home at 5 p.m. I have to ask him to help supervise their homework and baths; otherwise I'll get stuck doing everything myself, while he sends e-mail until I put dinner on the table. On weekends, the minute I come home from grocery shopping, he stops paying attention to the boys and turns the TV on. So I have to put everything away — and keep the kids from fighting over the snacks. It's not like I walk in the door, drop the groceries, and take a bubble bath. In fact, I can't remember the last time I took a bubble bath.

Brendan: So take a bubble bath already! No one's stopping her. Kate makes it sound like I ignore our kids every chance I get. That's not fair — and it's not true. But unlike Kate, I don't think they need constant supervision. I'm not a helicopter parent. And just because Kate comes home doesn't mean my workday is over. I wish she'd cut me some slack.

Kate: I'm too angry to cut Brendan any slack! It's like he's given up on our marriage but hasn't bothered to tell me. I mean, what else am I supposed to think when he stays out drinking? We haven't had a real conversation or gone on a date in years. I love Brendan and want our marriage to work, but we've lost our connection. I'm stressed out from doing all the chores and I'm worried that he's drinking too much. Things have to change fast. I hope that counseling will help us get back on track.

Brendan: I don't see how counseling will do any good. I bet Kate and the therapist will gang up on me. But, hey, I'll give it a try. Because if I don't, Kate will make my life even more miserable.

The Counselor's Turn

Kate and Brendan's marriage was a classic "pursuer-distancer relationship." The more Kate nagged, the more Brendan ignored her. At first she did all the talking — mostly berating him for his shortcomings. Meanwhile, he didn't say much. I could see how the relationship played out at home, with Kate screaming and Brendan walking away. They needed to restore balance to their marriage by changing their perspective, behavior, and communication techniques.

Every couple I've treated plays the blame game. As I told Kate and Brendan, it takes two to create conflict but it's easier to focus on what your spouse did wrong than it is to examine yourself. The attitude is, "I don't want to change, because I don't trust him to change" or "Why should I do all the changing?" But someone has to take the first step. Once that happens, everything starts to shift.

During the first two months of counseling, Kate refused to see how her perfectionism and controlling nature had pushed her husband away. The turning point came in a breakthrough session. Brendan complained that Kate was too bossy and critical. He also admitted that he was unhappy in their marriage — something he'd never verbalized but had demonstrated by avoiding Kate and staying out late. Brendan's newfound candor helped Kate accept some responsibility. She realized she'd need to change her approach if she wanted him to take more initiative and be more engaged.

Without question, Kate is a perfectionist. Her father had a drinking problem and Kate became a control freak, as many children of alcoholics do to compensate for their chaotic home life. She was in high school when her father died and her mother, a physician, started relying on her to help run the house and look after her younger brothers. Given Kate's family history, it was understandable that Brendan's drinking would trigger anxiety in her.

Brendan is a laid-back type B. Though he's ambitious and detail oriented about work, he never sweats the small stuff at home. He grew up in a family that avoided conflict, so he didn't learn how to express himself verbally. Instead, he ignored Kate's orders and shut down, which kept the pursuer-distancer dynamic alive.

Opposite types can find happiness together, but only if they bring those tendencies into better balance. Kate couldn't relax or tolerate household disorder, so she resented Brendan for leaving clothes on the floor and watching TV while groceries needed to be put away. It was hard for Brendan to express himself or to maintain structure outside of work, so he resented Kate's tidiness and her ability to speak her mind. They were both letting their differences drag the relationship down.

"It's very common to be attracted to somebody who's your opposite in certain ways," I said. "But over time — and with the addition of careers, kids, and a house — those same traits can undermine the relationship. You start to resent your partner for the very characteristics you once found attractive." Kate admitted she was drawn to Brendan in part because he was so calm and laid-back, and Brendan said he'd definitely admired Kate's efficiency. "The solution is to try to take on some of those positive traits yourself," I told them. "If you absorb just 10 percent of what your partner offers, it will change the dynamic."

I advised Kate to give herself permission to chill out with a good book or go for a run. When she feels overwhelmed, she must ask Brendan for what she wants — say, 30 minutes of alone time — instead of hoping that he'll read her mind and whisk the boys to the playground. What's more, Kate needed to relax her standards. "Is it more important that your kids wear matching socks or that there's harmony in the house?" I asked her. I also urged her to speak to Brendan nicely when she needed help around the house and then give him positive reinforcement for following through even if he didn't do it perfectly. "If you continue to order him around and criticize him, he won't be motivated to be more cooperative and engaged in family life," I pointed out.

Brendan needed to be more assertive with Kate. "Be honest if you can't fix something on her timetable or if you have to take a call," I told him. "You undermine Kate's trust when you leave the conversation or make a promise you can't keep." In addition, I advised him to take initiative and raise his standards. By being more proactive in helping with the kids and cleaning up, he'd show Kate that he's serious about being an equal partner, and that would help Kate calm down.

Kate and Brendan worked hard to transform themselves. During the year they spent in counseling, Brendan's company took off, allowing him to move out of his home office and rent office space. This has enabled him to draw better lines between work time and family time, which, in turn, has reduced Kate's stress. "She can rely on me to pitch in more, so there's less tension between us," he said. "I try to keep Kate informed about my work schedule so she can plan around it." Brendan also stopped staying out late once he understood why his drinking was causing Kate's anxiety. Now he plays poker with his buddies once a month — and calls home if the game runs past midnight.

Meanwhile, Kate is trying to let go of thinking she's always right and to tolerate some clutter. "Therapy helped me understand that perfectionism is my issue — and it's not fair for me to demand that Brendan share my standards," Kate said. "Every day I remind myself that the world won't end if the laundry doesn't get folded the minute it comes out of the dryer." She's backed off Brendan, which has made him more responsive. The other day the boys clogged the toilet with paper, Kate mentioned it in passing, and Brendan plunged it immediately. "Kate's happy I'm doing more, and when she's happy, she yells less and is more fun to be around," Brendan said. They try to spend time together after the kids are asleep and go on lunch dates during the workweek.

"Counseling made me realize that relationships need constant attention and open communication," Kate said. "Brendan and I had stopped paying attention to each other, and clearly, we weren't communicating effectively. We still have our struggles, of course. But we know how to fix things now, and that makes me feel like we're partners again."

Can This Marriage Be Saved?® is the most enduring women's magazine feature in the world. The story told here is true, although names and other identifying information have been changed to conceal identities.

Ladies Home Journal

More You'll Love